19 Comments
User's avatar
Alan's avatar

Looking forward to the book and the temperament self-assessment!

Rosie Langridge's avatar

I'm very much looking forward to your book.

On the subject of matching old understanding to new knowledge, we have found the blood group information from D'ADAMO extremely helpful. Not the diet but the typical personality, activity, relaxation and exercise needs. To the extent that I can predict the blood group of individuals I know with surprising accuracy.

I do recommend this aspect to you, Dr Remnant.

Remnant MD's avatar

Tell me more!

Rosie Langridge's avatar

I've just written you a long reply and Substack has dropped it. Is it possible to email you? Such an interesting topic I'm sure it's important.

Ayham Esmail's avatar

Humors and temperaments medicine has been distorted naive

The truth is Humors medicine is very accurate and creative

And not like modern medicine based on the principle of one drug for all patients

RDM's avatar

This looks so promising. Love the integration and the open searching. (FWIW, I see elements of TCM in here as well...)

Siobhan Mac Mahon's avatar

This is very similar to Ayurveda. Also to ancient systems of medicine. So interesting!

New Considerist's avatar

Very much looking forward to your book. Thanks for your efforts.

Molly's avatar

I’m so excited to learn about this! There is so much “health” info out there, and it feels like I’ve read everything under the sun. I’m starting to see that, when it comes to health of the body, the more simple something is, the truer it is - the Occam’s razor of health. We all have different personality temperament…why on earth wouldn’t our bodies match it?? So simple.

Remnant MD's avatar

The wisdom of our ancestors (no matter who you are or where you’re from) was in understanding the world qualitatively with such depth that we are still catching up 2000 years later with our quantitative approaches.

Molly's avatar

I’m so grateful to be on the course-correction wave. I’m also grateful to YOU for what you’re doing, and super excited about your book 🙏🏼

St. Mudphud's avatar

Excellent as always. I appreciate the ancient wisdom and hope to learn more. On the other hand, I wouldn’t discount modern understanding completely; I think there’s potential genetics/epigenetics and “biochemical individuality” that moves beyond reductionist and mechanistic explanations and pushes toward a more personalized understanding of a human person. As you know, Chris Masterjohn is one person whose work aims toward that modern personalized ideal. I think there’s a lot of potential to synergize the ancient with the new.

Remnant MD's avatar

Chris does a great job.

Absolutely.

The ancients had a qualitative understanding of the quantitative we insist on dissecting today.

The Social Thymocyte's avatar

Have you studied Chinese QiGong? I'm hearing parallels in what your describing and my own reading and practice

Remnant MD's avatar

it’s on the list.

There’s so much to learn!

MSB's avatar

Superb article. Indeed Traditional Chinese Medicine is another ancient system that is very similar to what you described.

Remnant MD's avatar

Yes, definitely. Forgot to include that one.

JD Smith's avatar

Subscribe

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Jul 15Edited
Comment deleted
Remnant MD's avatar

I love what I do.

Glad it shows.

All the best.