81 Comments
User's avatar
Marlee Salo's avatar

This is an amazing work that outlines something I intuitively felt modern medicine has gotten wrong. One thing I’d love to see but can find zero data on, is an in depth look at babies who did have a VKDB. Were the moms on any sort of medications before and during pregnancy? Did many have traumatic births. This would without a doubt provide more proof to the thesis.

Kds2026's avatar

I love your take on medicine, if only all doctors would ask why is the body made to do this in the first place, we would have a different system of medicine. Probably most doctors have no idea the history of medicine to even understand why they should question the status quo, who the system was built to benefit and how it was built to function.

Hoping your messages spread far and wide.

Rebekah Lee's avatar

Having my second baby in a few weeks, looking into this now. Rejected the shot with my first but did an oral dosage. I believe we ended up delaying the first dose a day or two just out of exhaustion. But he met all the criteria you laid out for being low risk. Just wondering if you think the issue is with immediate administration. If it was you, would you do some form of supplementation at some point? It seems like the most risk is of the late term bleeding. Would you wait a week to administer it orally or not administer it at all? Just curious, but also I know you might not have the answers to this.

Thanks! Appreciated your work.

Remnant | MD's avatar

My wife insisted to give the first oral dose out of fear then we just forgot about it…so…

AMEL's avatar

Anectodally, many parents report newborn jaundice after the Vit K injection. You mentioned liver issues, could these liver issues cause jaundice?

Remnant | MD's avatar

That’s a good point, and there’s a mechanism for this. Will have to look into it

Tanya's avatar

Never claimed to be.

I was so looking forward to how to do “real science” Oliver. 🥹

TDCNM's avatar

Of note, vacuum and forceps are still commonly used, especially vacuum. In areas where attending physicians are still present who were properly trained on the use of forceps, these are also still very common, in my experience.

Tanya's avatar

Who wrote this?

Tanya's avatar

You are welcome.

It doesn’t make sense. One of my comments repeated four times. 🤷🏼‍♀️

I wasn’t quoting you, I was asking a question.

Do you understand the difference between a scientific theory and a layman’s theory?

I am not a doctor.

MDs are obviously in the tens of millions if you go back just a few decades. Well over a hundred million if we go back to when vaccines were introduced.

Exaggeration undermines credibility and isn’t something a person does if discussing in good faith.

How have they been indoctrinated? Do you know what that even means?

You think there was a cryptic message in the term medical profession? I’m very sincerely asking. How does the medical profession poison our poor?

I don’t think Covid is a novel disease. I know it is. There’s a reason it’s called COVID-19. I’m very interested if you have reputable citations that support otherwise. And curious what it was before 2019 if you don’t think it’s new.

I also don’t think vaccines work. I know they do. Nothing has studied more than vaccines and the evidence they work is overwhelming.

If this ends up posting multiple times I apologize in advance. I am only replying once.

So can you answer my questions now please?

Latasha's avatar

The Israelites were told to circumcise infants on day 8. It is my understanding that vitamin K begins to rise on days 7 and 8. It’s obviously not a mistake but something that was intended and known (even though the didn’t know vitamin k specifically).

Eva's avatar

Absolutely fascinating thank you for your in depth reasoning, I had no idea of the underlying multiple systems.

I have a laymen’s question (one who hasn’t given birth to boot), would the letting the umbilical cord stay intact for longer which I’ve read is good for the baby help in any way with this also?

Remnant | MD's avatar

That’s a good question. Honestly, I am not sure - but I don’t think so.

Penny North's avatar

The baby is not deficient or have low vitamin K when the lab value is incorrect.

Baldmichael's avatar

Many thanks. Vit K injections for a non-existent problem. Suits big pharma only.

All this predicated on the fear of possible bleeding, not actual bleeding occurring.

"Doctors have assumed for decades that this is a mistake of nature"

Which just goes to show doctors are as thick as two short planks! It all comes out of evolutionary theory, the denial of a creator and designer. We are fearfully and wonderfully made.

User's avatar
Comment removed
Jul 16
Comment removed
Baldmichael's avatar

Hello child. Thank you for drawing my attention to a couple of minor spelling mistakes. I have edited.

By the way you have replied twice to me with the same reply. Does that make sense to you? :<)

And if you are going to quote me do make sure you do it properly. It is "We are fearfully and wonderfully made."

You believe in evolutionary theory do you? That explains it. You’re not a doctor by any chance?

The internet suggests there are 13 million doctors in the world right now so I suppose I can give you tens of millions, although it always helps to exaggerate to help make the point.

And yes, doctors really are indoctrinated fools. And to think I used to think they were clever before 2020. By the way ‘medical profession’ anagrams to ‘dim fecal poisoners’. That should have warned us!

In any event, I daresay you think that COVID 19 was a novel disease and that vaccines work.

Spadesman's avatar

WHOA WHOA WHOA! Excellent article Doc!

We did all home births so none of my children got Vitamin K but I have heard is that one of the reason's for it was for bleeding from circumcision. Supposedly the way we do it in the West is different, removes more foreskin than the traditional method so the child will bleed more. Have you heard that argument before?

Penny North's avatar

Yes. The cases of excessive bleeding from circumcision have been linked to why it is recommended. Btw - girls don’t get circumcised.

And if you are going to circumcise, wait until the baby’s own Vitamin K is elevated.

They use fear to bully you.

Spadesman's avatar

But then the hospitals would have to practice medicine rather than a blanket policy of giving ever children the same treatment. At least if they restricted it to males it would be somewhat making a science based decision.

Tanya's avatar

What do you think practicing medicine means? Every newborn has extremely low levels of vitamin K. That’s why it’s a “blanket” recommendation. It isn’t recommended because of circumcision. It’s recommended to prevent catastrophic brain bleeds.

Spadesman's avatar

Did you not just read the article where the author postulates that their is a reason that babies have low vitamin k, and perhaps they were DESIGNED that way, and that medicine THINKS it is correcting a mistake but could in actuality be causing more health problems then is solves?

Penny North's avatar

AGAIN, don’t take my posts as black and white or 100% restricted without exceptions.

There is some evidence that circumcision bleeding is/was a factor. AND brain bleeds are a factor, and…….

User's avatar
Comment removed
Jul 16
Comment removed
Penny North's avatar

And that group was not included in my comment as I was referring to American customs. You won’t find it in American hospitals - right?

Tanya's avatar

How are we to know you were only referring to American customs? Considering how circumcision of infants has dropped drastically over the last few decades and is no longer performed on the majority of infants, it wouldn’t be a custom either.

Does vitamin k reduce bleeding after male genital mutilation? Of course. Is it why it’s recommended? No. The major concern is devastating brain bleeds.

Who is “they”? I thought antivaxxers weren’t afraid so how is that even possible?

Spadesman's avatar

Jewish girls are not circumcised. FGM is not a normal procedure legally performed in America.

Remnant | MD's avatar

No haven’t heard that one, thanks

Cold liver's avatar

We don’t need exogenous K

Tanya's avatar

We don’t. Newborns do however.

Cold liver's avatar

They make their own. As we have for millions of years. Modern science now assumes we need so much exogenous help. We don't.

Spadesman's avatar

My wife trained as a midwife for a few years so she was the one who shared that detail with me.

Betsy Barnum's avatar

What you've highlighted is the biggest mistake that Western medicine makes, which is assuming that the body is flawed and doesn't know what it's doing, and that it needs intervention even from the moment of birth to be "healthy." Never even wondering if their intervention could be actually causing harm. This is of course writ large with vaccines. But even this seemingly benign injection has numerous potential consequences, as you outline. We come into the world with bodies that know how to be healthy.

Our bodies are wise beyond anything we have ever imagined, and your explanation here of why babies are born with low vitamin K is an excellent example. Our medical system and the people who run it need to drop the idea that they know more than the body of a newborn infant, or any other age human for that matter.

When my second son was born in 1983, it was with all of the low-risk conditions that you list. He was born at 2:30 in the morning in a hospital but in a room that was appointed like a bedroom, not a delivery room with all the bright lights and hard table, and I wanted to go home around noon rather than stay in the hospital another night and be woken up to have my blood pressure taken every three hours. They made me promise to bring him back to get that vitamin K shot, and I did. If I had only known! At least he was a couple of days old, not just a few hours, when he got it. And he doesn't have asthma or any other injury that I know of.

Tanya's avatar

I don’t know why my comment posted more than once.

I don’t care if you block me.

Are you not able to answer my questions?

User's avatar
Comment removed
Jul 16
Comment removed
Betsy Barnum's avatar

Midwives have been clearing newborns' airways since time immemorial. They have also not cut the umbilical cord immediately. The article on which my comment was posted went into detail about the potential harm of unnecessary vitamin K shots. There is evidence going back to the 18 century that vaccination is neither safe nor effective.

Tanya's avatar

So you agree interventions are often needed starting at birth such as clearing the airway. Maybe using a ambu bag until the baby is breathing on their own. Shortly after birth intervention is required to cut the umbilical cord. Medicine doesn’t think a newborn is flawed. They all have very low levels of vitamin K which is just a fact. No judgement. Something that can be life threatening can be rectified with a vitamin thanks to science. I am not sure if you really believe medicine doesn’t ever consider if treatments may be harmful. Not only is it considered, it doesn’t become a recommended protocol without evidence of efficacy and safety.

Vitamin K is not a vaccine.

Bodies don’t know how to be healthy. The human body doesn’t think or know anything. Infants have primitive reflexes and that’s it.

I don’t understand how someone who has spent a decade learning everything currently known about human biology and chemistry, and sometimes many more years focusing on a specialty isn’t capable of producing better outcomes with that knowledge. And we know they do.

The article is full of easily debunked falsehoods and zero evidence that vitamin K shots are harmful. The vaccine/inoculation used in the 18th century was so effective, we eradicated that horrific disease with a huge morbidity and mortality rate. Vaccines have eradicated two devastating viruses that no longer exist outside of two BSL-4 labs. That is astounding and evidence they work.

There is zero evidence for not vaccinating. There’s zero evidence newborns are better off without the vitamin K shot.

There is overwhelming evidence for vaccinating. There’s tons of evidence for the vitamin K shot.

I think the issue is antivaxxers don’t understand what constitutes evidence. They don’t know how to vet a source or an expert. They don’t factcheck things themselves to see if they’re actually true.

This opinion piece doesn’t name the author. That doesn’t raise the tiniest of red flags for you? Definitely claims to be a MD, but definitely isn’t.

Thank you for your respectful response.

Remnant | MD's avatar

I can’t tell if this is a parody account

Bob's avatar

Something we did not know when our last child was born

Vitamin K shot is not on the vaccine schedule

There was no mention of this prior to delivery

We chose no vaccines

In delivery room we are asked the question about Vitamin K

Never knew about it

Trying to research in a delivery room as your child is born

Cant get a signal, THEY say baby needs it

We say WTF, i guess if it is that important, go ahead

So sick and tired of the medical establishment

babablacksheep's avatar

Our midwife advised against the K shots for both our children born in her independent birth clinic in 2005 and 2008 for exactly this reason. Her explanation was not quite so in depth as this, but it was clear she had some intuition that there was a good reason to allow the blood to remain lower in K at birth in most cases. Due to a hematoma on one kid’s head, she did end up advising the shot. The other kid never got it. It was also clear that she was breaking the law and risking her license in doing so. She was a brave midwife and reading this makes me realize how fortunate we were to be under her care.

Cold liver's avatar

We don’t need exogenous K